9 Thanksgiving recipes that put a twist on tradition (2024)

There is comfort in eating a traditional Thanksgiving meal year after year. But eventually, revisiting the same spread can start to feel dull, no matter how perfectly delicious it may be. To inject your feast with a jolt of intrigue, this holiday we’re inviting you to put a twist on tradition.

What does that mean? With some dishes, we’re introducing new textures and flavors that are often missing from the holiday feast, such as the crunch of raw green beans and the heat of chipotle in a cranberry barbecue sauce.

Skip to end of carousel

Come cook with us

9 Thanksgiving recipes that put a twist on tradition (1)9 Thanksgiving recipes that put a twist on tradition (2)

Thanksgiving is right around the corner, and with The Post’s new Recipes experience there are more than 10,000 tested recipes at your fingertips.

End of carousel

Other recipes take Thanksgiving standards and turn them on their heads — a freshly baked bread with all the flavors of stuffing and (gasp!) pumpkin cake instead of pie. And then there are recipes where what’s old has become new again in our effort to achieve your best bird yet — see Becky Krystal’s recommendation to cook your turkey in a bag.

Advertisem*nt

We get it: Not everyone wants to try something new on Thanksgiving. In that case, maybe instead of replacing your family’s tried-and-true dishes, you add just a few of these recipes to make the meal that much more fun, flavorful and interesting. As we barrel toward the end of another year, who couldn’t use a little extra sparkle on their plate and in their life?

The Food team developed a fresh full menu to add something new to your spread this year. Here are our recipes.

We also have hundreds of tried-and-true holiday recipes among the more than 10,000 in our Recipes archive. Explore them all here.

Turkey in a Bag With Lemon and Herbs

I get it. Putting a turkey in a bag in the oven seems weird. And yet, I’m here to tell you that if you’re looking for moist meat, you can hardly do better. No brining required, either! Moreover, in testing I found that roasting — more like steaming — the turkey in a bag cut the expected cook time almost in half. (The bag is made of heat-resistant nylon, not the same as your typical plastic shopping bag.)

I took advantage of the closed environment by including lemon, garlic, apple, onion and herbs, which add subtle flavor to the meat and create delectable juices you can serve on their own, use in gravy or turn into broth.

And while you won’t get skin that’s as crisp as some other methods, it still turns an attractive golden color worthy of a place in the center of the table. Get the recipe. Becky Krystal

More turkey recipes: Garlic and Herb Roasted Turkey; Extremely Slow-Roasted Turkey Breast; and Tarragon-Butter Roasted Spatchco*cked (Butterflied) Turkey

Advertisem*nt

Roasted Butternut Squash With Feta and Dates

The viral TikTok pasta dish got us all in the habit of roasting feta (if we weren’t already), and this recipe from Kathyrn Pauline’s new book “Piecemeal” shows how well the sharp, salty cheese goes with winter squash, especially when you toss everything with red onions, rosemary and a simple vinaigrette.

Dates add texture and sweetness, making this interesting enough to do double duty as a side dish for the omnivores and a main course for the vegetarians at your table.

The best part: You can use any firm winter squash. The second-best part: The recipe is so simple you may find yourself using it as a jumping-off point. Which direction will you take it in? Get the recipe. — Joe Yonan

More vegetarian main dish recipes: Sheet Pan Persian-Style Stuffed Delicata Squash With Broccolini and Carrots; Roasted Portobello Mushroom, Pecan and Chestnut Wellington; and Pumpkin, Walnut and Sage Crostata

Cheddar Cheese Soup

This is the soup my husband’s family always orders whenever they’re at the Simon Pearce restaurant in Quechee, Vt. After spending a few Thanksgivings there, I became obsessed with the soup enough to track it down in their self-published cookbook, and it has become our go-to holiday meal starter.

With only a handful of basic ingredients, the soup doesn’t require much chopping or fancy techniques, and because it’s very rich, a little goes a long way, especially since you’ll need to save room for a multicourse meal to follow. Get the recipe. Olga Massov

More soup and appetizer recipes: Any Vegetable Instant Pot Soup; Fig and Fennel Caponata; Roasted Feta With Grapes and Olives

Advertisem*nt

Sausage, Apple and Onion Bread

These herb-scented loaves of freshly baked bread are studded with pieces of sausage, apple and onion, as if merging dinner rolls and stuffing (or dressing) into something new.

Soft, plush slices would make a great addition to your festive table and would be excellent for sandwiches the next day. Or for the extra ambitious, perform a feat of stuffing inception by baking this bread early in the week to use in your favorite stuffing recipe. Get the recipe. Aaron Hutcherson

More bread, dressing and stuffing recipes: Pillowy Pull-Apart Dinner Rolls; Bread Stuffing With Apples, Bacon and Onions; and Mushroom and Leek Cornbread Dressing

Crushed Potatoes With Tahini-Garlic Sauce

There can be such a great variety of flavors on a Thanksgiving plate. Textures? Not so much. I love mashed potatoes, but I often find myself craving crispy and crunchy textures to balance out the many soft dishes on the holiday table.

These potatoes are up to the task with a tender, creamy interior and a wonderfully crisp, craggy skin. They’re boiled (a couple days in advance if you like, to save time later), crushed to create some irregular edges and then roasted on high heat for the best of both spud worlds.

The nutty tahini-garlic sauce with sumac, lemon juice and parsley adds a little zip and a fresh take on holiday potatoes. Get the recipe. Matt Brooks

More potato recipes: Mashed Potatoes With Manchego and Olive Oil; Potato Roasties; and Hasselback Potatoes

Advertisem*nt

Skillet Sweet Potatoes With Brown Butter and Sage

Take sweet potatoes in a savory direction with this festive skillet recipe that is finished with nutty brown butter, crisp fried sage leaves and your favorite toasted nuts. The potatoes can be cooked a day or two ahead, freeing you for the day-of holiday tasks.

This side dish gives a nod to Lyonnaise potatoes, but instead of boiling, you slice, pan-fry and then cook the spuds in a skillet with onions, garlic and chopped sage. At this point, the potatoes can be refrigerated, and, when ready to serve, warmed in a skillet on the stovetop or in a casserole in the oven.

The toppings can be made ahead as well, the nuts can be toasted, and the sage leaves fried and kept at room temperature for two days. The butter can be browned and refrigerated until ready to use. Get the recipe. Ann Maloney

More sweet potato recipes: Sweet Potato Puree With Roasted Garlic; Sweet Potato Casserole (a Makeover); and Sweet Potato and Mushroom Gratin

Crunchy Green Beans With Almonds and Dates

While I’ll happily eat a green bean casserole for Thanksgiving, my 8-year-old won’t touch a cooked green bean with a 10-foot pole, so I’ve started to prepare this vegetable by not cooking it at all. Not only does it free up in-demand stovetop or oven space, but the crunchy, raw side makes for an ideal foil against all the richness of many Thanksgiving dishes.

Here, green beans are cut on the bias, tossed with Medjool dates and a mustardy-lemony dressing, and topped with a shower of toasted almonds for a result that delivers a crunch, sweetness, brightness and tartness.

The best part is, for a holiday when you’re juggling timings of various warm dishes, this one gets served at room temperature. Get the recipe. Olga Massov

More vegetable side recipes: Simply Splendid Roasted Vegetables; Roasted Butternut Squash and Red Onion With Tahini and Za’atar; and French’s Green Bean Casserole With From-Scratch Mushroom Sauce

Advertisem*nt

Chipotle Cranberry Barbecue Sauce

Spiciness is usually absent from the holiday menu. So for heat lovers, this barbecue-style sauce with chipotles in adobo and cranberries is just the ticket. (Feel free to adjust the amount of chipotle in the sauce to match your audience.)

And if you’re someone who always has trouble with gravy, consider this as an excellent replacement to serve with the turkey, stuffing and potatoes. Get the recipe. Aaron Hutcherson

More cranberry sauce and gravy recipes: Red Wine Cranberry Sauce; Roasted Garlic Gravy; and Chile Pecan Gravy

Skillet Pumpkin and Apple Cake

I am not really a pie person (even my pumpkin “pie” is more like a cheesecake). For years, I have begged/pleaded/threatened to share a recipe for a Thanksgiving cake, and now, it has finally happened.

Riffing on a pumpkin loaf recipe from my grandparents and inspired by the retro pineapple upside-down cake, I created a skillet dessert that features a tender, fluffy crumb gently spiced with cinnamon and cardamom.

To create an eye-catching topping, cranberries and apples are arranged in a hot mixture of butter and brown sugar. All you need to do is turn it out of the pan for an instant wow. Get the recipe. Becky Krystal

More dessert recipes: Silky Pumpkin Pie; Cranberry Tart With Gingersnap Cookie Crust; and Pecan Tassies

9 Thanksgiving recipes that put a twist on tradition (2024)
Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Chrissy Homenick

Last Updated:

Views: 5756

Rating: 4.3 / 5 (74 voted)

Reviews: 81% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Chrissy Homenick

Birthday: 2001-10-22

Address: 611 Kuhn Oval, Feltonbury, NY 02783-3818

Phone: +96619177651654

Job: Mining Representative

Hobby: amateur radio, Sculling, Knife making, Gardening, Watching movies, Gunsmithing, Video gaming

Introduction: My name is Chrissy Homenick, I am a tender, funny, determined, tender, glorious, fancy, enthusiastic person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.